Ever since I got back to Columbus, I kept hearing people rave over Jeni's Ice Creams as being the best in town. Pshaw, I thought. Graeter's is clearly the best. What were these people talking about? But everytime I went to the North Market, there was always a line snaking through the tight aisles for Jeni's "gourmet, artisanal ice creams." I figured what was the harm in trying, right?
A couple of weeks later I found myself in the Short North with an hour or so to kill. I snapped some photos, had some coffee, and thought I'd treat myself to some ice cream. Right away I loved the decor. It looks like a modern creamery - clean lines, calm colors accented with bright yellow stools (that evoke milk cans a bit), light fixtures that look like milk jugs. Plus they had a display of enlarged polaroid photos.
The people working were extremely friendly and let me try about 7 flavors. Now, since this isn't any old ice cream parlor, but a "gourmet, artisanal" place, you don't find your normal 32 flavors. They have nine signature flavors: Salty Caramel, Gravel Road, Dark Cocoa Gelato, Pistachio & Ashland County Honey, Black Coffee, Thai Chili, Lemon Yogurt, Queen City Cayenne, plus a fresh sorbet of the day. Jeni Britton, the founder and ice cream maker extraordinaire, is all about using local foods, so most of her flavors are seasonal, and reflect the produce of Ohio.
I tried something with a lavender base, but opted for the sweet corn with black raspberry sauce. (There were still summer flavors when I visited.) See descriptions of the current flavors here. Looking over the list again, I'm amazed I ever came to a decision. Oh, and the cones are all made in-store and were delicious. It was the best sugar cone I have ever had - cone alone.
As you can see, I quickly became a convert. I don't think it's the sort of ice cream I'm going to always want - have simple tastes (plus there are a couple of Graeter's flavors that will always bring me there), but I will definitely go back. Change is sometimes definitely for the better.
Recent Comments